Skip to main content

ChurchGeniusPro vs Tithe.ly

Tithely offers a free online giving plan plus paid church management, church app, and website plans. ChurchGeniusPro offers a Free plan and two paid plans that include accounting. This page compares the two using each provider’s official public information.

Last verified October 10, 2026 from official public sources.

✓ offered as a built-in feature (for ChurchGeniusPro, on at least one plan — see Pricing). — not found as a built-in feature in the provider’s official public website, pricing pages, and documentation as of the verified date; it may be available through integrations or may have changed since. Text notes describe a partial form, a specific plan or product, an add-on, or the scope stated.

Pricing

How each one is priced

ChurchGeniusPro

Free plan at $0 (up to 50 people); Standard $20/month (up to 100 people, accounting with bank sync for up to 3 accounts, check-in, worship planning, volunteer scheduling); Pro $40/month (unlimited people, payroll, check scanning, and the advanced AI assistant). Application setup is free, and every feature can be tried free for 2 months with no credit card.

See full pricing

Tithe.ly

Free Online Giving is $0/month plus processing fees (card 2.9% + $0.30; ACH 1% + $0.30). Church Management is $72/month, Mobile Church App $89/month, Website $19/month, and All-Access $119/month. Paid plans include a 30-day free trial.

Official pricing page (opens in a new tab)

Where Tithe.ly is stronger

Where ChurchGeniusPro differs

  • Accounting is built in on Standard and Pro. Tithely’s official materials say it does not provide general-ledger accounting and integrate with QuickBooks Online instead.
  • Payroll is included in Pro; we did not find payroll in Tithely’s official materials.
  • ChurchGeniusPro charges a flat plan price and does not take a percentage of gifts; online gifts are processed through your own Stripe account at Stripe’s standard fees.
  • On Pro, a built-in assistant takes typed or spoken requests and reads photographed checks and documents into entries.

Tithe.ly may suit you if…

Your first need is online giving at no monthly cost, you want a custom church app or website from the same vendor, or you already keep your books in QuickBooks Online.

ChurchGeniusPro may suit you if…

You want church management and accounting in one system, payroll on Pro, and one monthly price for people, giving, check-in, and worship planning.

Questions

ChurchGeniusPro vs Tithe.ly: FAQ

Tithely’s official materials say it does not provide general-ledger accounting services; it integrates directly with QuickBooks Online.

More comparisons

About this comparison. This page was prepared by ChurchGeniusPro and last verified on October 10, 2026, based on information published on Tithe.ly’s official website, pricing pages, and public documentation as of that date, linked beside each entry. Products change frequently, and features, plans, and prices may have been added, removed, or modified since our review. Please consult each provider’s own website for the most current information before making a purchasing decision. If you believe anything on this page is inaccurate or out of date, please contact us and we will review and correct it promptly.

Trademarks. Tithe.ly and all other third-party product names, brands, and trademarks referenced on this page are the property of their respective owners. They are used here only to identify the products being compared. Their use does not imply — and should not be interpreted as implying — any affiliation with, sponsorship of, partnership with, or endorsement of ChurchGeniusPro by those companies, or of those companies by ChurchGeniusPro. This page intentionally uses no third-party logos, screenshots, or other content.

2-month free trial · Free setup & migration · 30-day money-back guarantee

Ready to make church management effortless?

Let your software do the busywork — so you can spend less time on admin and more time with people.

Start 2-Month Free Trial View Pricing